Planning a cruise is exciting! The promise of the sun, the sea, and the promise of new places to explore. But one question looms in your mind, with the potential of ruining the entire trip: should I book shore excursions through the cruise line, or go exploring on my own?
Jump to:
After trying both approaches across the Mediterranean and the Caribbean, I’ve learned that the right answer depends on your travel style, the port, and even your comfort level with local logistics!
Here’s what I’ve discovered from real experience, and what I wish I’d known before my first sailing.
- Check out how we planned our 7-day Mediterranean cruise shore excursion itinerary, with stops in Italy, France, and even Tunisia.
- Also, insult my handy guide on how to pick the right cruise for families or adults only, since the excursions offered through the cruise might differ depending on the demographic.
The Benefits of Booking Shore Excursions Through the Cruise
- Safety and reliability. Cruise lines vet their partners, so you’re in good hands. And if your excursion runs late, the ship will wait for you (so you don't have to start a new life on a remote island in the Caribbean). That peace of mind is definitely worth consideration, especially for first-time cruisers or those traveling with kids.
- Local insight. You’ll get knowledgeable guides who bring local history and culture to life. On my first stop in Naples, I learned more about Pompeii from our guide than I ever could have from a travel book.
- Less stress. No need to navigate taxis or transportation in a new language with only two weeks of Duolingo under your belt... Everything is handled, so you can focus on enjoying your day.
That said, the trade-off is freedom. You follow someone else’s schedule and often share your time with a large group.
Why I Sometimes Skip Excursions and Explore Independently
Once I got comfortable traveling, I started experimenting with DIY shore days. Check out my first time cruiser tips for your first time! If you like doing your own thing, you'll probably love it too.
You can move at your own pace, stop for a spontaneous gelato, or linger at a quiet beach without rushing back to the bus crowded by other sweaty cruisers. It’s also more affordable, especially for families or longer cruises.
If you’re confident navigating local transport or using Google Maps, exploring on your own can turn an ordinary port stop into an adventure that feels uniquely yours.
This approach also makes it easier to connect with locals. I had such an interesting chat with a café owner in Marseille or you might stumble upon a street musician in Barcelona (the type of things you just can't plan for).
Want to save this?
We'll email this post to you, so you can come back to it later when you're planning your trip!
Family-Friendly Ports Perfect for DIY Exploring
Some destinations are tailor-made for families who prefer to explore on their own:
- Marseille, France – The Old Port is just a short walk from where most ships dock, making it easy to spend the day strolling through markets, sampling fresh pastries, and soaking in seaside views without needing a tour guide. Check out my one day itinerary in Marseille for more details!
- Barcelona, Spain – A vibrant city filled with culture, food, and family-friendly attractions. From the Gothic Quarter to Park Güell, it’s simple to explore independently using taxis or public transport! Ideal if you want flexibility and time to enjoy tapas at your own pace. Read more about our week in Barcelona with the family.
- San Juan, Puerto Rico – Colorful, historic, and compact, this port is perfect for walking. You can climb the old fortress walls or browse artisan shops without worrying about transportation.
- St. Maarten – Taxis and rental cars are easy to find, letting families visit beaches, lookout points, and local eateries all in one relaxed day.
Each of these ports offers a safe, walkable, and engaging experience! The kind that turns a cruise stop into a genuine family adventure.
When to Choose Cruise Line Excursions Instead
There are times when I absolutely recommend booking through the ship:
- Remote destinations where taxis or tours are limited (think Alaska or smaller Caribbean islands).
- Adventure activities like scuba diving, zip-lining, or volcano hikes that require certified operators (check out cruise activities in the Bahamas for more examples).
- Long drives inland — such as Rome from the port of Civitavecchia.
If the logistics are complicated or you’re nervous about missing the ship, a cruise excursion is the safer bet.
Tips for Deciding Between a Shore Excursion and DIY Exploring
- Research each port before your trip. Look up maps, walking distances, and local transportation.
- Check the port’s safety record and read traveler reviews. Especially on sites like Cruise Critic or official tourism pages.
- Mix it up. I like to book a couple of excursions for big-ticket experiences and do the rest on my own. It keeps the trip balanced.
- Time your return. Always plan to be back at least two hours before the ship’s departure if you’re exploring independently.
Final Thoughts
In the end, it’s not a matter of right or wrong. The real question is: What floats your boat? It’s about what makes you most comfortable and excited to explore.
For me, the best cruises blend both worlds: a few guided excursions for insight and ease, and a few independent adventures where I can get lost (just a little!) in the charm of a new city.
Adapted from Food Drink Life with original insights and first-hand experience added for travelers planning their next family cruise adventure.
